Strategies in Approaching AI as a Catholic Institution

Written by Robert Delaney, coordinator of religious studies and faith formation, and Jennifer Richard, director of academic innovation, Mount Carmel Academy, Archdiocese of New Orleans, jrichard@mcacubs.org

Conversations about artificial intelligence (AI) in education have become almost all-consuming. Advertisements for AI educational tools fill our inboxes, academic dishonesty policies have had to be entirely revised, and the nature of modern education has been questioned. The task of helping learners navigate this new technology can seem overwhelming. Our first temptation may be to think that if we are able to set the right policies in place or purchase AI detection software, then we can mitigate the problems caused by AI. While this approach is practical and maybe even correctly ordered, our primary responsibility requires a more relational approach that affirms our human dignity in an increasingly dehumanizing world. 

Our students feel just as overwhelmed, if not more so, by this emerging technology. This feeling was made especially clear when a group of rising seniors at our school, Mount Carmel Academy, were asked to share their thoughts on AI in a panel discussion for the entire faculty. The students emphasized what they most want from their teachers: guidance. One student made the need for formation clear when she described the weight of learning to navigate new technology: “We’re the generation that has to figure it out.” Especially with the Holy Father’s emphasis that schools take a pivotal role in maintaining our humanity in an AI world, we must reflect on how we can guide our students in understanding what AI is. We need to guide students to learn how to utilize AI with virtue. 

The following four strategies are ways schools can provide students with the guidance they need. 

Strategy 1: Let the Mission of Catholic Education Guide the Conversation

The mission of Catholic education, as the Second Vatican Council lays out, is that students understand their identity as beloved children of God the Father and learn how their natural gifts when “redeemed by Christ contribute to the good of the whole society” (GE, 2). With this vision in mind, we can begin to understand the limitations of AI as a pedagogical tool that can never replace person-to-person interaction. 

One of the first things AI cannot replace is our evangelical task as educators. An AI chatbot, while it may provide answers to certain theological queries, cannot proclaim the kerygma. An AI bot does not know the Good News as an existential reality. Only those who, like the Samaritan woman at the well in John’s Gospel, have encountered Christ can encourage others to come and see Him (Jn 4:29). 

We must also remind ourselves that AI is artificial in that it does not experience what it “knows.” As Pope Leo explains in his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, “so-called artificial intelligences do not undergo experiences, do not possess a body, do not feel joy or pain, do not mature through relationships and do not know from within what love, work, friendship or responsibility mean” (MH, 99). Chatbots cannot replace our intelligence because our intelligence is ordered to something higher than just data processing: it is ordered towards love. We have to remind our students that reading Dickens or understanding physics has the profound opportunity to change us by sparking within us a curiosity or wonder that makes us human. In fact, such a call by the Pope should require us to examine our curriculum to ensure our education is not just about acquiring information but about the formation of heart and mind. If we do so, then our students will be able to humanize an increasingly dehumanizing world. 

Strategy 2: Listen Instead of Making Assumptions

One of the greatest mistakes educators can make is assuming we already know how students feel about AI or how they are using it. We can make broad generalizations such as “Students use ChatGPT for everything,” or “Kids these days would rather use AI than think for themselves.” Such generalizations neglect our responsibility to understand our students. The USCCB’s framework on ministry to youth, Listen, Teach, Send, reminds us that our first task is to listen to young people because they are “not a data set, a demographic category, or an abstract monolith; rather every young person has a name, a face, and a soul, ‘each with the reality of his or her own life” (LTS, 23). 

To better accomplish this goal, our school brought in a director of AI literacy whose task was to begin a conversation with our students. These conversations and surveys revealed that many students did not understand what AI tools are, how they work, or how to properly evaluate responses. This data allowed us to create learning opportunities for students to fill these gaps, such as learning sessions that teach the student body the history of AI-based technology, the importance of evaluating responses with critical thinking, and the responsibility to understand the environmental and human impact of the corporations that license this technology.

Teachers must take the time to listen to their students on this issue. Ask them to share their thoughts on AI with the faculty so that you can better understand their concerns. Our panel interview at the end of the year was eye-opening to us. 

Strategy 3: Form a Common Language

Imagine walking from your economics class having been told that AI prompting is a needed skill for future employment, and then your English teacher insinuates that utilizing AI is a grievous moral failing. This all-too-common reality causes confusion, anxiety, and frustration among students. Talking with our students revealed that they desperately want clear, consistent expectations from their teachers. 

Working with both students and faculty, the administration developed a leveled framework to help students, parents, and teachers alike better understand how and when AI could be used in different learning environments. The framework begins with zero AI allowed to AI being used to help with the creative process. The framework—along with the expectation that students cite any AI usage—gave students clarity of how and when AI would be used. It also served as an opportunity for teachers to think through how much AI usage, if any, they deemed appropriate for a given assignment. 

Strategy 4: Emphasize Process over Product

Artificial intelligence, with its ease of producing finely polished language, exacerbates students’ focus on grades over learning. Pope Leo reminds us that true education “is a long journey requiring patience, and therefore needs time for development and for engagement with reality beyond appearances” (MH, 140). In light of this, our school has been intentional about making the thinking process visible in each classroom. The goal is to help students understand that the process of brainstorming, outlining, drafting, and revision is integral to learning. Recognizing that the learning process is as important, if not more so, than the finished product requires a mindset shift for students, parents, and educators alike. When this value shifts, students are less likely to turn to AI to replace their thinking. Teachers can reinforce this expectation by asking students to document and reflect on their process: share drafts and revision histories, workshop ideas in class, and submit reflections about their thinking. These powerful practices not only help students develop academic integrity but also cultivate ownership over their work and celebrate their growth.


Artificial technology will continue to evolve, and our policies will as well. What remains central in education is the personal influence of the educator upon the student so that they may know and love the truth. The strategies above help maintain the humanizing goal of education while acknowledging AI literacy as a necessary skill for our students’ futures.