Written by Christie Bonfiglio, Ph.D., founder/faculty, Program for Inclusive Education at University of Notre Dame, and founder/consultant, Better Together Learning Design, LLC, cbonfigl@nd.edu
Walk into almost any Catholic school classroom today, and you’ll immediately notice something beautiful–learner variability. Students bring unique strengths, interests, experiences, and ways of learning. Some excel academically while struggling with organization. Others are socially connected but experience anxiety that interferes with learning. Still others have strong cognitive abilities but find it difficult to regulate emotions or behavior. This diversity is not the exception; it’s the reality of today’s Catholic schools. If we truly believe that every child is created in the image and likeness of God, then our schools must be prepared to support every learner and cultivate environments where each student can flourish.
To support this diversity, Catholic schools must move beyond a singular focus on academics and embrace a comprehensive lens of our mission–forming scholars, citizens, and saints. This whole-child perspective recognizes that academic success depends on far more than content knowledge. It requires attention to the executive functioning skills that enable learning, including planning, organization, attention, and problem-solving. Equally important are social-emotional competencies that help students manage frustration, persevere through challenges, build relationships, and respond appropriately to difficult situations.
These skills are not separate from learning—they make learning possible. When students struggle in one or more of these areas, the challenges often surface as behaviors that disrupt learning. Rather than viewing these behaviors simply as misconduct, educators need to recognize them as important forms of communication that point to underlying needs and opportunities for growth.
MTSS: Tier 1 is Most Important
Given the variability, Catholic schools must move beyond isolated interventions and embrace a comprehensive Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS) that addresses the whole child. When educators think about behavior supports, it’s easy to focus on students receiving intensive interventions. Yet the most important tier of MTSS is Tier 1.
Tier 1 is where we intentionally build a culture of belonging. It is where classrooms become communities characterized by safety, relationships, high expectations, and shared responsibility. It’s where every student experiences dignity, connection, and the confidence that they matter.
Many public schools implement Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) to establish positive school climates and teach behavioral expectations. Catholic schools can successfully implement this framework while grounding it in their distinctive mission. Behavioral expectations can be explicitly connected to gospel values, school virtues, and the dignity of every person. Rather than focusing solely on compliance, Catholic schools should cultivate communities where students learn what it means to love, serve, forgive, persevere, and care for one another. When PBIS is infused with Catholic identity, it becomes more than a behavior framework—it becomes a way of living the mission of the school.
When Students Need More than Tier 1
Even in schools with strong Tier 1 supports, some students will require more targeted interventions. When this happens, educators often ask, Why is this student behaving this way? Or why don’t they do what is expected? While these questions are understandable, a more useful and instructional question is, “Is this a ‘can’t do’ or a ‘won’t do’ problem?”
The answer fundamentally changes how we respond. A skill deficit (“can’t”) means the student lacks the knowledge or ability to demonstrate the expected behavior or complete the task successfully. A performance deficit (“won’t”) means the student possesses the necessary skills but lacks motivation, incentive, or consistency to apply them.
Accurately distinguishing between these two types of deficits is essential because it determines the intervention:
- When students can’t, we teach. We explicitly develop the missing skills, provide supports, and create opportunities for guided practice.
- When students won’t, we focus on increasing motivation. We make learning more engaging, provide meaningful choices, reinforce effort and success, and ensure students see value in the expected behavior.
When educators mistake a skill deficit for a performance deficit—or vice versa—they often implement interventions that miss the underlying need. The result is frustration for both the student and the teacher. Asking the simple question, “Can’t or won’t?” helps us move beyond managing behavior to understanding it, allowing us to respond in ways that promote both learning and belonging in the school community.
Behavior Is Communication
Consider a student who refuses to begin an independent writing assignment. From the outside, it appears to be noncompliance. But what if the real challenge isn’t willingness? Perhaps the student struggles with executive functioning. They know how to write, but they cannot determine where to begin, how to organize their thoughts, or how to prioritize the steps required to complete the assignment.
The task feels overwhelming, frustration grows, and avoidance becomes the visible behavior. The behavior isn’t the problem—it’s the communication.
When educators recognize the underlying executive functioning skill deficit, the intervention changes. Instead of deeming this a “won’t do” issue and increasing consequences for refusal, they implement “can’t do” (skill-building) interventions. They provide planning supports, visual organizers, task chunking, modeling, and guided practice. The student’s behavior improves because the underlying need has been addressed.
Building Schools Where Every Student Thrives
Creating inclusive Catholic schools requires more than responding to behavior after it occurs. It requires proactive systems that cultivate belonging, teach essential skills, and respond to learner variability with wisdom and compassion.
Sometimes students need more. When students have a skill deficit, we teach. When students have a performance deficit, we inspire, engage, provide meaningful choices, and reinforce effort and growth.
As Catholic school educators, we are called to see beyond the behavior and recognize the child standing before us. The simple question, “Is this can’t or won’t?” can transform not only our interventions, but also our relationships with students. When we answer that question accurately, we create classrooms where students experience belonging, receive the support they need, and are empowered to flourish academically, socially, emotionally, and spiritually.
Interested in hearing more from Christie Bonfiglio, Ph.D.?
Watch her recent webinar, When Students Don’t—Is it Can’t or Won’t?, in the NCEA special education series: